Add compose option. There is no option & there is no "pencil" as you say.
Nowhere to compose email. No "pencil".
Could you please message us on Twitter at @AOLSupportHelp or on Facebook at AOL Customer Care? We'd like to look more into the issue you're experiencing. In case you do not have a social media account, we are also available at: https://help.aol.com/contact/
Looking forward to your reply!